1 - 5 - Week 1 - 5 Locard_'s Exchange Principle (08_25).txt

(6 KB) Pobierz
[MUSIC]
We said that forensic science is
the application of science to criminal
justice,
but the boundaries are not so firm.
The boundaries are actually quite fuzzy,
because many of the concepts and ideas of
forensic science
can also be used in other areas, in other
fields.
For instance, they can be used in art.
The picture on the right is a picture of
the playwright William Shakespeare.
And for many years it was believed that
this
particular picture really was a picture of
William Shakespeare,
painted by someone who either knew him, or
actually was looking at him at the time.
And that made it very valuable, because it
was the only such painting in existence.
Then someone did forensic analysis of the
paint.
They looked at the paint chemistry.
They determined what kind of paint it was,
and it turned out to be a kind of paint
that had first been used in the year 1818,
more than 200 years after Shakespeare
died.
So, it turns out that this painting wasn't
so special after all,
and we still don't know what Shakespeare
looked like.
Forensic science can also overlap with
archaeology.
We've said that forensic science can help
you reconstruct the events of the past,
and of course that is what archaeologists
always seek to do
and we will have a case study later on
which illustrates this point.
Forensic science techniques can also be
important in sport.
For instance, in major sporting events,
there is drug testing for the athletes
and this uses similar techniques that
might
be used, for instance, in a narcotics case.
Forensic science can impinge on
international politics.
The picture on the right was taken at the
site of a mass grave in Bosnia.
These poor people here were killed as part
of the Bosnian conflict
and the investigators are trying to
determine who they were,
how they died,
and who killed them.
In addition, forensic science can come into
play during disasters.
In the 2004 tsunami that struck Aceh in
Indonesia
and Thailand and other places in the
Indian Ocean,
there were so many people killed,
so many bodies, that forensic scientists
from the region
had to be mobilized to help with the
identification.
Forensic science, however, is not that new.
It's roughly 100 years old.
And one of the interesting things about
forensic science is that it was
being done in fiction books before it was
actually being done in reality.
So on the left, you see the instantly
recognizable Sherlock Holmes.
And if you read the Sherlock Holmes
stories,
you'll find a great deal of good forensic
science in them.
Curiously, Sherlock Holmes was not created
by
a forensic scientist or a police officer.
He was created by Sir Arthur Conan-Doyle,
who had just qualified as an eye doctor
and started writing the stories in
order to
pass the time while waiting for patients
to show up.
And he turned out to be much more
successful as an author than a medical
man.
[BLANK_AUDIO]
We consider that the real founder of
Forensic Science is this man here -
a French professor called Edmond Locard.
And here on the slide, you see a
very substantial quotation which is
attributed to Locard,
and it really summarizes what Forensic
Science is about.
Talking about the criminal - "Wherever he
steps, whatever he touches, whatever
he leaves, even unconsciously, will serve
as a silent witness against him.
Not only his fingerprints or his
footprints,
but his hair, the fibres from his clothes.
The glass he breaks, the tool mark that he
leaves.
The paint he scratches, the blood or semen
he deposits or collects.
All of these and more, bear mute witness
against him.
This is evidence that does not forget.
It is not confused by the excitement of
the moment.
It is not absent because human witnesses
are.
It is factual evidence.
Physical evidence cannot be wrong, it
cannot perjure itself.
It cannot be wholly absent.
Only human failure to find it,
study and understand it, can diminish its
value."
So, this is a very powerful quotation.
And one of the most important parts of
it is that final sentence.
[BLANK_AUDIO]
When forensic science goes wrong,
when innocent people are sent to prison
because of forensic science,
it's not because the evidence, the
physical evidence,
the data collected from the evidence, is
wrong.
It's because of the human factor.
There is a human error somewhere in the
chain which has made that mistake.
It's a very valuable quotation, but it's a
very long quotation.
So it's very helpful just to remember the
short form of this quotation -
"Every contact leaves a trace."
And of course when Locard uses the term
trace,
he's thinking of the traces in his
quotation there.
Some of them are very difficult to
observe.
Fingerprints can be very hard to find.
Fibres can be almost microscopic.
Tool marks can be hard to discern.
Blood or semen stains can actually be
invisible to the naked eye.
So many of these traces to which Locard
refers to here, are very difficult to
find.
Sometimes, however, traces can be pretty
obvious.
Here's a curious case from the Times of
London
where a burglar managed to leave his false
teeth behind.
Now I have real teeth,
I'm no expert on false teeth,
but I think you'd notice if you didn't
have them in your mouth.
Here's another case,
and it's a case I like very much because
it actually comes from my hometown.
My hometown is not the most interesting
town in the world
but this is one of the most interesting
things that's ever happened there.
And it concerns this Builders Merchants
called Elliott,
and around the back in their backyard, they
had a big tank of diesel
and somebody would climb over the back
wall
of the yard, steal some of their diesel.
So the manager decided to do something
about it,
and he put razor wire on top of that back
wall.
So, soon after, when the first employee
came
in one morning and went around the
backyard,
he noticed something rather unpleasant on
the razor wire,
and it was a finger which had been cut
off.
Now this was a very easy crime to solve,
because it's a pretty obvious trace
and all the police had to do was to go
around to the
local emergency room and ask them if they
had anyone there with a finger missing.
And the culprit was subsequently arrested
and convicted of this crime.
[BLANK_AUDIO]

Zgłoś jeśli naruszono regulamin